An Unexpected Mix of Tropes

Introduction:

Now what most people imagine when they hear “Howl’s Moving Castle” is the wonderful and beautiful Ghibli film. It is a charming romance, with wonderful animation and stunning art. Hayao Miyazaki has incredible skill in animation and that film is a prime example of it. It is an excellent film that really contrasts the whimsy of magic with the horrors and pointlessness of war.

Ghibli Film Poster

Book Cover

The book by Diana Wynne Jones, that Ghibli’s film is based off of, is very different in a couple of very interesting ways: 

First of all Howl is much more of a play boy and a coward in the book. It’s not that he isn’t honorable and kind. It’s just that he spends most of the book running away from his lovers, the Witch of the Waste, and his other responsibilities. 

Secondly Sophie and Howl’s romance isn’t the only romance in the book. Sophie has some sisters who have their own plot trying to avoid fate and who want to fall in love. One of whom has fallen in love with Howl’s assistant / apprentice, Michael. 

The third difference is that in the book the war hasn’t started yet. So, instead of our characters facing the mechanized horror of carpet bombings they face the Witch of the Waste and her mission to steal Howl’s power so she can create the perfect man. 

There are of course many other minor differences between the book and the film but I don’t want to dwell on that here. There are plenty of commentaries on those fun differences on youtube. Some of them are quite fun as they use their artistic skills to reimagine the characters.

If you haven’t read the book yet though I highly recommend that you do! It is one of those delightful books where the characters are aware of the fantasy tropes they live in and try to escape those predetermined fates. It has some lovely messaging and its delightful to see Howl and Sophie slowly come to love each other. 

All Aboard!!! The first train to explore a world that inspired a Ghibli film! 

Spoilers ahead if that kinda thing bothers you! 

〰️

Spoilers ahead if that kinda thing bothers you!  〰️



What is Inspiring about Howl’s Moving Castle Film?:

I’ll keep this short. It is beautifully animated with some of the best art Ghibli has put to screen! The characters are so charming and the story about how to have confidence in yourself is very inspiring!

Also the profound message about what it really means to have someone’s heart and what being forced to go to war can really cost everyone involved. Of course it’s not a Miyazaki film without heavy critiques of war and just how awful it is. It also isn’t a Hayao Miyazaki film with some crazy airships either. Not to mention how attractive they manage to make Howl in this movie.

It’s Just a masterpiece of a film everyone should check out!


What is Inspiring about Howl’s Moving Castle Book?:

As mentioned earlier there are plenty of differences between the book and the film. However, that's not what interested me the most while I was reading the book. No, what caught my attention was the fascinating mixture of tropes that Diana Wynne Jones uses to craft this story. 

Tropes such as:

  • Three Sisters

  • Wicked Step Mother

  • Evil Witch

  • Mentor Death

  • Cursed / Missing Royalty

  • Trickster Hero

  • Mirror Character

  • Believing in yourself

  • Beast and Beauty

And most Bizarrely of all:

  • Portal Fantasy Protagonist

Starting at the top: We begin this story almost the same way we do in the film. With Sophie working at her family’s hat shop. Sophie believes however that since she is the eldest of three daughters she is doomed, like in the fairy tales, to lead an ordinary life with no excitement or fortune. She talks to the hats she makes and they seem to find the perfect owner every time. 

Her step mother encourages Sohpie’s world view because she underpays Sophie and makes insane profits off of her hat making skills. Sophie’s sisters let her know this when they divulge that they are trying to escape the supposed fates of second and third sisters by switching places and using magic to look like one another. (This later leads to shenanigans when its revealed that Michael and Howl are both courting Sophie’s sisters and are unaware of the switch). 

Because the Witch of the Waste wants Howl and hears that he is courting a girl from the hat shop (one of Sophie’s sisters). So she barges in and curses Sophie. Making Sophie look like an old woman and preventing her from telling anyone about the curse. 

I do want to take a moment to talk about the scene where the Witch of the Waste curses Sophie because it is fantastic! The Witch of the Waste continually asks for hats to try on from Sophie as as she tries them on she mentions in what ways they don’t suit her. Like Dimples, Youth, and Mysterious Allure. With each hat taking those attributes away from Sophie. Just such smooth and ingenious writing, that you don’t notice until the curse is already wrought. 

The Mentor Death is of course Howl’s Master, Mrs. Pentstemmon, that he does his best to avoid because he believes himself to be a disappointment. Quite the contradiction for someone as vain as himself. But the Witch of the Waste kills Mrs. Pentstemmon and it is so abrupt. It is a moment where the rug is very effectively pulled out from under your feet.

The whole reason for all of these curses and missing royalty is because Howl is good at running away from his problems. Running away from the deal he made with the Witch of the Waste, and she’s leveling anyone that stands in her way. Howl, however, is a trickster so he is very good at wriggling out of problems. 

Of course, The Witch of the Waste is unrelenting and it is made very apparent that Howl and her are mirrors of each other. Howl is what she was hundreds of years ago and she is what he might become in a few hundred years. That is why she wants him and his power, because the Witch of the Waste knows they belong together. 

Oh!!! What a fantastic use of the Mirror Character Trope! I love it! It plays so well with Sophie’s arc which is to trust yourself. To accept your own power and rewrite your own narrative. One of the best reveals in the books is the fact that Sophie has been cursing herself this whole time. Turns out that Sophie is in fact a very powerful, untrained yet powerful, sorceress. When she talks to objects, like hats, she’s casting a spell on them changing their fates. 

So, when she first came to the castle Howl has been repeatedly trying to remove the curse that turns Sophie into an old woman. But she keeps on reapplying it when she talks down to herself. Sophie has to come to the fact that some part of her finds comfort in being an old woman with no future and it is such amazing character writing and development. 

This whole mess began because Sophie was making her belief in fate into a reality with magic she didn’t fully understand. That the older sister never led an interesting life. Only when she’s able to confront that false belief, and help Howl face his insecurities are they able to break Howl and Calcifer’s contract and stop the Witch of the Waste. 

Honestly one of the best versions of Beast and Beauty romances I’ve seen. Ronatasy Shadowdaddies and brooding wizards wish they had what Sophie and Howl have. It is genuinely such a touching romance where they both recognize each other's flaws and accept one another despite them.

The most shocking development in this book for me though was learning that this fantasy book was in fact a Portal Fantasy!!! Just told from the perspective of one of the fantasy land’s inhabitants instead of the portal fantasy hero. Who is Howl. 

Howl is from Earth! Our Earth; specifically Wales in the modern day U.K. He somehow stumbled into a magical portal transporting him to Sophie’s world full of magic and fate. Once there he show immense talent and cunning with magic so Mrs. Pentstemmon took him on as a student. There he made an ill fated contract with a falling star, giving up his heart, and ran off on his own. Howl then created his moving castle and hid from the magical world and his own family in Wales. Bouncing between the two, ignoring responsibilities and feeling like an alien in both worlds. 

What an astounding use of the Narnia portal! Just such a unique take on Portal Fantasy that I wasn’t expecting at all. It explains why Howl feels so out of place in Sophie’s world, and why he loves spreading horrible rumors about himself. He is a person between worlds and because of that he can never stand still. It is only when Sophie recognizes how much she cares for this vain, clever, insecure, kind, and miraculous man. When she steps in to save him when he is finally able to stand still and see what he has.

Such a beautiful romance that the book builds up to so elegantly. A very different romance to the film where Howl is the perfect gentleman and Sophie just has to find confidence in herself. However, I cannot pick a favorite because both are done so excellently. Same with the rest of the differences between the book and the film. They are such a unique mix of tropes and plotlines that it is impossible to truly put one above the other.


Final thoughts:

What can we learn from these two stories about creating a classic fantasy story? 

The first thing to cross my mind is to not be afraid to mix up tropes. Both the film and the book did this in different ways but they both were able to craft compelling stories out of them. It may not matter what tropes you use in your story. But as long as you mix them up and execute them in an interesting way you will get a fantastic story out of it!

The next thing I’d say is pick a character with a unique perspective. In both the film and the book one could argue the Howl has the more interesting life, and conflict. Although it is Sophie that we follow. I would say that is because while Howl is a classic Wizard and a classic Portal fantasy protagonist we’ve seen his type of story before. Sophie though, we haven’t seen much of a character like her take on fate itself and forge her own way through a story like Howl’s. So, that in fact makes Sophie the most interesting character to tell this story through. 

Don’t be afraid of action. As decentralized the action is in both the book and film they are not afraid to show off how the devastation of magic and conflict appears on screen. In the film it’s transformed wizards fighting bombers. While in the book we get some incredible magical battles between Howl and the Witch of the Waste. Just pure spectacle that Sophie is able to finally join towards the end with her trusty walking stick.

That’s why Howl’s Moving Castle is so inspiring in both its book and film iterations. It speaks to us about the stories we tell ourselves and having the confidence to change those stories. Finding our own confidence and breaking the binding spells we put on ourselves. I love that message so much and hope that it continues to inspire all of us as we move forward into the future. 

Thank you for coming aboard to Journey though the amazing world of Howl’s Moving Castle. What other Ghibli stories should we visit in the future? Feel free to reach out and let me know!

We are disembarking now. Mind yourself, and I hope to see you again on future travels!



Looking for more Inspiration? Continue Here:

C.C.Christensen

Hi I’m the Conductor of Inspiration Station! I am the one how catalogs the different engines that bring in all of these inspiring things! I am the main author of this site but if you see another author say hi to them for me!

Next
Next

Laika’s Wildwood